The Pony Bar

Image of The Pony Bar
Photo - Alex Hall

 Alex Honorable Mention Full menu WiFi available Regularly has real ale

1444 1st Avenue
New York NY 10021
(Upper East Side)



Open 1500-0400 Mon-Fri, 1200-0400 Sat/Sun.

Handpumped Cask Beers: 2
Craft Keg Taps: 19

Beers: Beer range varies

Nearest subway: 72nd St(Q), 77th St(6)


19 rotating domestic taps and 2 casks.

Directions – Q train to 72nd Street, walk east one long block, turn left on 1st Avenue for three short blocks. Alternatively, 6 train to 77th Street, walk east along East 77th Street for three blocks, turn right on 1st Avenue for two short blocks.

Alex says

Exactly the same formula as the original Pony Bar in Hell’s Kitchen (now closed), where all beers are $7 each – standard strength ones coming in 14oz measures while stronger or rarer offerings come as an 8oz pour. The beer menu is on an easy to read TV monitor. The bar’s website mirrors the list on the monitor in real time. Great bar food is served. (2/2015, updated 11/2015, further updated 2/2017)

Jezza says

Very similar to the Hell's Kitchen Pony (edit - now closed). American drafts only, with lots of good choices.

Back to the pub search.

Upload your own image of The Pony Bar